azrienoch · Dec 2, 2011 at 07:40 am

Carrier IQ Creeps Out Everyone

Over the last week, Carrier IQ received quite a lot of attention.  First, TrevE was served a Cease and Desist letter from Carrier IQ, including a prepared statement they insisted TrevE release on his website, denouncing his work.  The Electronic Frontier Foundation responded on TrevE’s behalf, calling the C&D a violation of constitutional rights, and malicious.  Carrier IQ apologized, calling the C&D, “misguided,” but made a statement denying many of the allegations.

Then TrevE released a video proving that every single allegation that Carrier IQ denied their software was capable of doing, their software actually does.  And apparently not even the mighty iPhone is free of Carrier IQ data mining.

In the last few days, pieces of the story made their way to The New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, Forbes, Huffington Post, CNN, MSNBC, Fox News, and more–not typically the venues to announce mobile tech news.  There’s congressional interest in the matter, with Minnesota Senator Al Franken demanding answers about Carrier IQ by 14 December 2011.

A flood of statements poured in from companies of all sorts, proudly announcing that their products do not use Carrier IQ.  Statements from companies that use Carrier IQ are now trickling in, too.  Of the statements by companies who admit to using Carrier IQ, all of them include a list of data they do not collect.  That may be confusing because they immediately contradict TrevE’s video.

For example, from T-Mobile’s statement, “T-Mobile does not use this diagnostic tool to obtain the content of text, email or voice messages, or the specific destinations of a customers’ internet activity, nor is the tool used for marketing purposes.”

From Sprint’s statement, “We do not and cannot look at the contents of messages, photos, videos, etc., using this tool. The information collected is not sold and we don’t provide a direct feed of this data to anyone outside of Sprint.”

The contradiction between these statements and the reality of the Carrier IQ software comes from a failure of explanation on the part of the carriers and of Carrier IQ.  It may be true that they do not receive that data, but the software most certainly collects it.  If their software was unable to collect all this information, it’d be much more plausible that they never receive it.  Why create diagnostic software capable of collecting more information than you collect?  It makes no sense, and these responses are frankly unbelievable.  They’re also astoundingly slimy semantic dodges, if not lies.  And if not lies, the burden of proof is on the carriers, and yet to be fulfilled.

What baffles me is that, had users had an opt-out option–a full disabling of Carrier IQ software–there would be no issue.  Or, at least, very little issue.  But that’s not what we have here.  In fact, Sprint said, “The Sprint privacy policy makes it clear we collect information that includes how a device is functioning and how it is being used.”

In other words, the Terms of Sevice itself is the opt-out option.  If we don’t like it, we don’t have to use Sprint’s services.  The problem is, what is made “clear” by the privacy policy, isn’t.

We called Sprint Customer Service yesterday to see about getting a contract and a new smartphone, and specifically asked about Carrier IQ.  The customer service representative, Jason, assured me that Sprint did not use Carrier IQ.

Now, I believe this is a singular example of ignorance-nearing-idiocy.  Sprint obviously, publicly admits they use Carrier IQ’s software.  Nothing in itself to pursue.  However, it goes far to show just how much of an option we have, here.  If a random customer cannot be informed of their contractual obligations because a customer service representative isn’t even informed of those contractual obligations, the It’s-in-the-Terms-of-Service defense does not work.

On top of that, the next step in exposing the depth of evil to which Carrier IQ is used is proving that the only way “law enforcement offers could log into a special Sprint Web portal and, without ever having to demonstrate probable cause to a judge, gain access to geolocation logs detailing where they’ve been and where they are,” is using Carrier IQ.  (Source: Sprint fed customer GPS data to cops over 8 million times.)

Regardless of whether Carrier IQ was used to help the Feds spy, I doubt the Sprint privacy policy actually says that Sprint shares information with law inforcement.  I don’t know.  Maybe.  I’ll call and ask Jason at Sprint tomorrow.


_________
Want something on the XDA Portal? Send us a tip!

azrienoch

azrienoch is an editor on XDA-Developers, the largest community for Android users. View azrienoch's posts and articles here.
Mario Tomás Serrafero · Aug 1, 2015 at 03:54 pm · 1 comment

PSA: You Can Optimize Your Note 4’s Recents Menu & RAM

The Note 4 never had the fastest Recents Menu, and despite its 3GB of RAM, its app-holding capabilities only got worse on Lollipop. The infamous RAM bug that plagued the S6 is indeed an annoyance on the Note 4's 5.0.X ROMs. Rumors of an update to fix all of this were confirmed with the first reports of the 5.1.1 update for the Russian Note 4, which seemingly improved the Recents Menu and RAM management. But it'll be a long time...

XDA NEWS
Mario Tomás Serrafero · Aug 1, 2015 at 01:33 pm · no comments

XDA Picks: Best Apps of the Week (July 25 – Aug 1)

Apps are at the front and center of any smartphone experience, and with over a million apps on the Google Play Store and new apps being submitted to our forums every day, staying up to date on the latest apps and games can be a hassle. At XDA we don’t discriminate apps - if it’s interesting, innovative, original or useful, we mention them. The XDA Portal Team loves apps too, and here are our top picks for this week.  ...

XDA NEWS
Mathew Brack · Aug 1, 2015 at 09:00 am · 2 comments

Voices Of XDA: Orbiting The Earth With Android

Editor’s note: This week's feature has been written by forum member RowHanSolo and takes a look at the exciting prospect of launching satellites fitted with little more than an Android phone as an onboard computer. From a university to NASA, multiple projects like this have launched!   Technology is an ever-growing industry, regardless of which corner you look at. However, each area of technology has its limitations on what it can do and how far it can expand. For satellite technology,...

XDA NEWS