Will Verduzco · Jan 11, 2012 at 06:00 pm

MythBusters XDA Edition: “Optimized” Compiler Toolchains

If you’ve compiled an Android kernel or two, you have undoubtedly noticed that there are more than a few cross-compiler toolchains at your disposal. Although Google offers its own toolchain as part of the Android Native Development Kit (NDK), several aftermarket options exist—many of which promise higher target device performance.

So what’s a new developer to do? Since kernel devs ultimately wish to eke out as much device performance as humanly possible, choosing the wrong toolchain could potentially have disastrous results. And without any firm guidance as to which toolchains work best, it’s easy to get lost in the available choices.

To alleviate this problem, XDA Recognized Developer Ezekeel decided to run extensive benchmarks with four popular toolchains. And much to the content of the obsessed, he has even tested the toolchains with and without the popular flags -fgcse-after-reload and -ftree-vectorize. In the words of the developer:

I have read of lot of praise for these optimized TC from different kernel developers that all claim that these do much better than the offcial Google TC, however to my knowledge up until now nobody actually took the effort of investigating the effect of the TC and most devs simply assume that a TC marketed as optimized by their creators is actually performing better.

So to investigate the performance of the different TC, I compiled a kernel (GLaDOS kernel for ICS) with the following four different TC:

1. Offical Google arm-linux-androideabi-4.4.3 (part of android-ndk-r7)
2. CodeSourcerey arm-2011.03-41-arm-none-linux-gnueabi
3. Linaro android-toolchain-eabi-linaro-4.6-2011.11-4-2011-11-15_12-22-49-linux-x86
4. Mjolnir arm-eabi-4.6-mjolnir-20111006

Also while I was at it, I investigated the effect of the compiler flags ‘-fgcse-after-reload’ and ‘-ftree-vectorize’ (see https://github.com/Ezekeel/GLaDOS-ne…f32ee#comments) by compiling a version with the CS TC which did not include these flags.

I performed the following two tests for the kernels:

Test I: Measured the bootup time including a rebuild of the Dalvik-cache after a wipe (2 times).
Test II: Performed a benchmark with AnTuTu Benchmark v2.4.3 including CPU/memory, 2D and 3D graphics (3 times).

Long story short, the allegedly optimized toolchains yielded no real world performance gains. At this point, you’re probably salivating at the mere thought of viewing the benchmarks. To get started, continue on to the original thread and join in on the discussion.


_________
Want something on the XDA Portal? Send us a tip!
TAGS:

Will Verduzco

willverduzco is an editor on XDA-Developers, the largest community for Android users. Will Verduzco is the Portal Administrator for the XDA-Developers Portal. He has been addicted to mobile technology since the HTC Wizard. But starting with the Nexus One, his gadget love affair shifted to Google's little green robot. He is also a Johns Hopkins University graduate in neuroscience and is now currently studying to become a physician.
Mario Tomás Serrafero · Mar 27, 2015 at 04:13 pm · 2 comments

Should You Get Wear? Wearer’s Practical Observations

Wear is said to not offer enough for mass adoption, even though its been in the market for over 9 months. I personally have a Gear Live which I purchased 8 months ago, and my experience with it has had its ups and downs throughout my time with it. For the longest time, I was not able to recommend the platform to anyone. Since then, a lot of updates have hit Wear watches, some improving battery life, others changing the...

XDA NEWS
GermainZ · Mar 27, 2015 at 01:15 pm · 2 comments

SlimRoms: Updates on the Horizon

SlimRoms' website has been experiencing technical difficulties for the last month or so, but it's good to know the team is working hard and is still on top of things. The SlimRoms GitHub repos are getting updated with some major changes showing up. Most notably, some projects are getting a new 5.1 branch: lp5.1! A new, revamped and open source website is also in the works, with a look inspired by material design. We also got a tip about an...

XDA NEWS
Emil Kako · Mar 27, 2015 at 12:47 pm · 3 comments

Your Favorite Wireless Charger?

Wireless charging is becoming more and more common as many OEMs are now starting to include this feature in their flagships. There are already dozens of wireless chargers to choose from on the market today, but quality definitely varies. For those of you who charge your devices wirelessly, let us know which charger is your favorite and why.

DISCUSS
Share This